Grey rock, yellow rock or BIFF? 7 co-parenting communication methods

There are several methods to communicate more calmly with the other parent after a separation. Which one fits best depends on how things are between you. If you can still talk things through reasonably well, I-statements and nonviolent communication help. If things often go wrong, the BIFF method, yellow rock or grey rock help.
Below are 7 methods. First an overview, then for each method what it is, when it helps and a short example. At the end you will find two tips that help with every method.
Overview: which method helps when?
| Method | What is it? | When does it help? |
|---|---|---|
| BIFF method | Replying briefly, informatively, friendly and firmly | When you get an angry or blaming message |
| Yellow rock | Brief and businesslike, but friendly | When there is a lot of conflict, but some room for friendliness |
| Grey rock | Responding as briefly and neutrally as possible | When the other parent keeps seeking confrontation |
| EAR | Showing that you are listening, without agreeing | When the other parent is angry or upset |
| I-statements | Saying what something does to you, without blame | When you want to raise something difficult |
| Nonviolent communication | Saying what you need in four steps | When you can still talk things through reasonably well |
| Parallel parenting | As little contact as possible, each parent handles their own part | When talking things through really no longer works |
1. The BIFF method
What is it? BIFF stands for Brief, Informative, Friendly and Firm. You only answer the question and don’t respond to any blame. Bill Eddy of the American High Conflict Institute developed the method.
When does it help? When you receive an angry or blaming message and still want to reply calmly and clearly.
Example. The other parent writes: “I want you to drop the children off at 10 on Saturday. You never stick to agreements anyway.”
A BIFF reply: “Hi, I’ll drop the children off at 12 on Saturday, as the schedule says. If you’d like to agree on a different time, please let me know a few days in advance. Thanks!”
You can read more, with a step-by-step example, on the BIFF method.
2. Yellow rock
What is it? You keep your messages brief and businesslike and you don’t respond to blame. But you stay friendly, with a simple greeting or a thank you. You don’t have to act cold if you are not a cold person.
When does it help? When there is a lot of conflict, but just enough room to be friendly. Or when the coldness of grey rock doesn’t suit you.
Example. The other parent writes: “You still haven’t paid for the school trip. Typical.”
A yellow rock reply: “Hi, thanks for letting me know. I’ll transfer my half of the school trip today. Have a good day!”
More examples are in what is the yellow rock method?
3. Grey rock
What is it? You respond as briefly and neutrally as possible, without emotion. That way the other parent has nothing to react to.
When does it help? When the other parent keeps seeking confrontation or tries to get to you. The less you say, the less there is to argue about. You do still answer a question about the children, but with the facts only.
Example. The other parent writes: “I heard you’ve got a new boyfriend. You didn’t waste any time.”
A grey rock reply: you don’t reply. The message isn’t about the children, so you don’t need to respond. If you do want to send something, keep it to one neutral word, such as “Noted.” Better not to write “OK”, because that can sound as if you agree.
When grey rock works and how to use it with children, you can read in what is the grey rock method?
4. EAR: showing that you are listening
What is it? EAR stands for Empathy, Attention and Respect. In a few words you show the other parent that you hear them. That does not mean you agree. This method also comes from Bill Eddy.
When does it help? When the other parent is angry or upset. People who feel heard often calm down sooner.
Example. The other parent writes: “Emma was completely wound up when she came back. What’s going on at your place?”
An EAR reply: “Hi, I hear that you’re worried about Emma. I understand that. It’s good that you look out for her so well. Shall we look together at how to make the handovers easier for her?”
You show that you hear the worry (empathy and attention) and that you value the other parent (respect). You don’t respond to the accusation “What’s going on at your place?”
5. I-statements
What is it? You say what the other parent’s behaviour does to you, instead of blaming them. You name three things: what happens, how you feel about it and what the consequence is. So not “You’re always late”, but “When the children arrive later than agreed, I get restless. Then dinner and bedtime become a rush.” I-statements come from the American psychologist Thomas Gordon.
When does it help? When you want to raise something difficult without the other parent immediately getting defensive.
Example: “When I only hear at the last minute that the handover isn’t going ahead, it gives me a fright. I can no longer arrange childcare then. Could you let me know a day in advance from now on?”
6. Nonviolent communication
What is it? A way of talking in four steps, developed by the American psychologist Marshall Rosenberg:
- What do you see? Describe what happened, without judgement.
- What do you feel? Say what it does to you.
- What do you need? Say what matters to you.
- What do you ask? Make a concrete request.
When does it help? When you can still talk to each other reasonably well and want to find a solution together. When there is a lot of conflict, it is often too long and too personal. Then BIFF works better.
Example: “The last two times Sam came to me, his PE bag wasn’t with him. I’m disappointed about that. It matters to me that Sam can just take part in PE. Could you put his PE bag in his backpack from now on when he comes to me?”
You can see the four steps: what happened, what you feel, what matters to you and a concrete request.
7. Parallel parenting
What is it? Each parent handles their own part of parenting, with as little contact between you as possible. You only discuss what is really necessary.
When does it help? When talking things through really no longer works and every contact leads to an argument. The aim is to keep the children out of the conflict.
In the Netherlands and Belgium there is also a guided form: parallel solo parenting. Each of you then talks to your own counsellor, through youth care services.
Two tips that help with every method
- Wait a moment before you reply. You don’t have to answer a message that upsets you straight away. Put your phone down and read it again later, when you are calm. You often soon regret a reply written in anger. If it’s urgent, such as a sick child, you answer sooner of course. You can find more tips in how do you communicate with your ex after a separation? Do you ask ChatGPT to help with your reply? Then first read why a chatbot is so quick to tell you you’re right.
- Put agreements in writing and in one place. Don’t discuss arrangements about the children on the phone or at the door. You can reread a message, but not a phone call. Keep them in one place, not in between messages from friends and family. That saves a lot of discussion about what was actually agreed.
Which method do you choose?
You don’t have to choose just one method. Most parents combine a few. Some rules of thumb:
- Does it usually go well? Use I-statements or nonviolent communication for the difficult conversations.
- Have you received an angry message? Wait a moment first and then reply using BIFF or yellow rock.
- Does the other parent keep seeking confrontation? Use grey rock. Is there a little more room, or does the coldness not suit you? Then choose yellow rock.
- Is talking things through no longer possible at all? See whether parallel parenting could work for you.
Many parents also search for “communicating with a narcissistic ex”. Grey rock, yellow rock and BIFF are often recommended for that. You don’t have to give the other parent a label to use any of these methods.
None of these methods protects you against violence or threats. If you or the children are being threatened or abused, get help. In the Netherlands, call Veilig Thuis on 0800-2000, free and day and night. In Flanders, call 1712. In an emergency, call 112.
How BeNice helps
BeNice is an app for separated parents. Many of these methods are already built in.
- The Feedback Coach reads every message to the other parent before it is sent, with BIFF as the standard. If there is a lot of anger in your message, it suggests a calmer version. The message stays the same. You decide what you send.
- The filter protects you from angry and accusatory messages. If you receive an angry or accusatory message, you read a calm version with only the content.
- Everything in one place. The messages, the calendar and the costs are together. So you can always read back what you agreed.
- The BeNice Coach is a personal coach that only you can see. You can share what is bothering you and prepare a calm reply together.
Would you like to try it yourself? You can try BeNice free for 7 days.
Sources
- Bill Eddy, How to Write a BIFF Response, High Conflict Institute, 2007
- Bill Eddy, Calming Upset People Fast with EAR, High Conflict Institute, 2018
- Tina Swithin, Implementing Yellow Rock Communication When Co-Parenting with a Narcissist, One Mom’s Battle, 2022
- Medical News Today, Grey rock method: What it is and how to use it effectively, updated April 2025
- Thomas Gordon, Parent Effectiveness Training, 1970
- Marshall B. Rosenberg, Nonviolent Communication, 1999


